Songs Discovered Under Especially Ugly Rocks
I wanted to just jump into this one, but after I came up with the theme, I realized I'd already written something that fit it wel. I wrote it 11 years ago, when I took over the blog One Week One Band and explained my love of The Walkmen over 28 posts. I regret deleting my Tumblr and losing all that writing, so I'm glad the One Week One Band stuff is still up.
In my first post after the intro, I talked about discovering this band I love through a commercial for the Saturn Ion. And that's what I'd like to discuss today: the embarrassing and uncool ways I've been introduced to good music. Might as well start with The Walkmen.
Music: "We've Been Had" by The Walkmen
Point of Contact: car commercial
I’ve found so many bands by seeing them live. They were an opening act for an already cherished group, or a friend wanted to see them and I said “of course I’d like to come” without knowing anything about what I was about to experience. I’ve found bands through mix CDs traded during high school lunch periods, through record reviews, through interviews where artist x went on and on about how much she was influenced by artist y, and I was already into x, so y was my next logical listening destination. I inherited Sinatra and Springsteen from my parents. I worked extensively with my college radio station and found artists because they sent me CDs with attached notes saying “Please, for the love of God, listen to my album and put the single into heavy rotation, I promise I actually sound like Tom Waits.” Band names and album covers have drawn me into unknown territory a hundred times.
But I learned about The Walkmen through a commercial for the 2003 Saturn Ion. My parents were in the room and I asked them what the song was, sure that the piano melody had been from some famous thing. And they didn’t know, of course, because the song had been written in 2000, on the first day the band had been in a studio together, and then had been released on an EP in 2001 and an album in 2002.
The song was about growing up and rejecting the urge to cling to everything that’s come before. The singer literally says “I hear the songs and the words don’t change, I write them out of the book right there.” “We’ve Been Had” is about moving from D.C. to New York trying to be your own person. It’s as good a song as The Walkmen ever wrote, and it’s an ideal introduction to them, even if it came to me from a pretty undignified place.
When I say “undignified,” I’m not saying that putting your music in a car commercial is a bad thing for a band to do [note from 2026: I don't think it's a great thing to do, either, but if it keeps a roof over your head, it's nowhere near as compromising as a lot of shit people engage in now to make a living off their art]. I’m saying it’s embarrassing when you’re an incredibly uncool kid who has a transcendent moment watching a commercial for a product you aren’t old enough to legally use. There are more romantic versions of my story out there, I’m sure— a cute older boy/girl with great taste put “We’ve Been Had” on a mix for a much luckier kid than I was, and that started his or her obsession with The Walkmen, for example. And I was watching ads.
Oh well. If that car commercial is my gateway to the albums, the songs, the half dozen live shows, the friend I made coming back from a Walkmen show on the bus back to Tenleytown (what’s up, Kylie), the people I connected with over this music, the joy I felt every time a new Walkmen record came out every two years, like clockwork— if that commercial is what eventually lead to me enjoying each of these experiences, and it is, then that commercial is something I’m beyond grateful for.
Music: "Designs on You" by Old 97's
Point of Contact: Le Pain Quotidien retail playlist
For the first half of 2012, my last semester of college, I interned for SiriusXM. I had two bosses simultaneously, one who was great (Ron Ross, 90s on 9 and The Pulse) and one who was a sleazeball (_____, several EDM stations).
Brief aside, because you can't call somebody a sleazeball and not follow that up with some justification. A friend I don't want to get in trouble, who'd interned for different stations at SiriusXM a year earlier, let me know the sleazeball station programmer was apparently famous for using the internship program as a dating pool. He was in his 30s and would get involved with all these 18-to-22-year-old women, and it got so bad my friend's boss, a woman, tended to hire male interns so as to not feed any more college girls into that meat grinder. I looked that programmer up just now and he has a Catholic Electronic Music playlist on his website.
Interning for the good boss meant sitting in on The Pulse's morning show a couple times every month. I'd wake up at 2am, take the metro to the New York Ave-Florida Ave-Gallaudet U stop on the red line and, time willing, get a quick breakfast from the only open restaurant, Le Pain Quotidien. My sleep apnea and narcolepsy hadn't been diagnosed yet and I had a full course load, so I'd sit, mortally exhausted and brain dead, in this bakery at 3am while a single person heated up plastic bagel sandwiches for Gallaudet students, ATF agents and me. One morning, "Designs on You" played over the restaurant's speakers.
"Designs on You" is a great song. It's got a dBs jangle and these funny, cruel, sad lyrics about being the other man in a bride-to-be's life. It's from Old 97's Satellite Rides, and Rhett Miller's got that Evan Dando superpower, where he can write great songs and is good looking enough that one of the other tracks on that album is about dating Winona Ryder. And I do not come here to praise alt-country's handsome grandsons, but knowing that about Miller makes "Designs on You" lyrics like "I don't want to get you all worked up / except secretly I do" even meaner. From everything I've heard, Miller seems like a good guy (Neko Case speaks highly of him), but this song, written from the perspective of a man trying to get in an old flame's head and make her question her life choices, is a perfectly evil little pop-rock nugget that works even better when you know it's being sung by a guy who could be a model. Not that he thinks of himself that way– the song is more self-deprecating than that.
It was an uncomfortable experience, loving this song, because so much of my identity pushes against "person who can't stop listening to music Le Pain Quotidien would feel comfortable playing at 3am." That's a Sheryl Crow, Imagine Dragons world. That's a place where Foster The People might sound too angular, where the music being piped in needs to be calming enough that customers don't have to raise the volume on the business podcasts in their earbuds. But I don't know, maybe Le Pain Quotidien isn't Kenny G Land. Maybe "Designs on You" wasn't a qualitative outlier. The company that curates their music made this shareable image:

Music: "Hallelujah" by Leonard Cohen
Point of Contact: Shrek
This is probably the case for a lot of people around my age (I was 12 in 2001). I first heard one of the all-time greats, Leonard Cohen, via John Cale's cover of "Hallelujah" in Shrek. Later in the Year of Shrek, I got the film's soundtrack on CD as a gift, and it features Rufus Wainwright's take on Jeff Buckley's take on John Cale's take on "Hallelujah." I listened to that thing a lot.
I've never been able to fully warm to Buckley's music because I can't help but connect him to all the American Idol, a capella, network TV Christmas special covers of "Hallelujah" he unwittingly inspired. It's a short line from Jeff Buckley to Josh Groban and Pentatonix. It's not his fault, I know. I've never listened to any Rufus Wainwright. John Cale gets a pass, in part because I love a lot of his other music. One day, I'll give Wainwright a fair shake and maybe he'll get a pass, too.
Watching Shrek as a tween, wondering what this beautiful song was, I didn't know I was listening to a version of this sexual, despairing, triumphant epic and I couldn't have seen the tidal wave of incoming losers who'd make it even less sexual, despairing and triumphant than Wainwright had for the Mike Meyers uncanny valley fart movie. And now we've got worship music versions of a song whose original lyrics go "You say I took the name in vain / I don't even know the name / But if I did, well, really, what's it to ya?" and which accounts for both a holy and a broken "Hallelujah." In some ways, it's the snobby Le Pain Quotidien dilemma, only instead of Alec Baldwin's favorite jazz club, "Hallelujah" is being played at megachurch Christmas services. I just have to be glad it's getting out to people, the same way it got out to me. That restaurant didn't make "Designs on You" easy listening music, the many church versions of "Hallelujah" that "Weird Al" Yankovic it into being about Jesus' love don't turn a Buddhist Jew's commitment to life into an endorsement of one religion.
Music: Les Savy Fav
Point of Contact: friend's complaint
I don't know what song it was, but I believe this was 2006, so it may have been something off Inches. My friend Sam and I were waiting for a show to start at Bimbo's 365 Club and a song came on over the PA. "This is the only Les Savy Fav song I like at all," Sam said. I had thought Les Savy Fav were some ponderous French band, not a slick post-punk unit with English-language lyrics. I made a mental note to check out this group my friend had just trashed.
Music: "Hello Kitten" by Hefner
Point of Contact: algorithm guess based on music I no longer enjoy
When I was a junior or senior in high school, Pandora came out and I was first introduced to Hefner because I told the site I was desperate for anything similar to Morrissey's Vauxhall and I.
Music: "No One Knows" by Queens of the Stone Age
Point of Contact: snowboarding video game
I somehow didn't knowingly hear "No One Knows," which has to be Queens of the Stone Age's biggest hit, until it appeared on the soundtrack to the 2003 snowboarding video game SSX 3. Other featured bands included Ima Robot and Finger Eleven. And we're far enough down the page that I can admit I bought the Ima Robot album, too. You're either not reading this or I can trust you with that shame.
SSX 3 was a cartoonish version of snowboarding, which was fine, because I've only ever been skiing and my idea of snowboarding is already cartoonish. Here, for example, is the selectable character Psymon, whose name is a combination of "psycho" and "Simon:"

The game had a smart feature where the higher off the mountain you were, the more distant the music sounded, so you'd be racing the other characters and the soundtrack would be playing normally, and then you'd hit a ramp and do an extremely anime version of a snowboarding trick, i.e. you'd flip upside down, balance your pinkies on the board and spin 2,160 degrees, and in the 10 seconds between you taking off from the ramp and landing back onto the snow, the music would get drenched in reverb and the sound of rushing wind would fade in. The effect is hard to describe, but it was exhilarating to a teenage dork and you'll have to take my word for it that fucking Ima Robot sounded badass in this context.
Oh no I hit the wrong button on my keyboard here's Psymon again

Music: "Karma Police" by Radiohead
Point of Contact: Now That's What I Call Music!
In 1998, the Now That's What I Call Music! series made it to America and that Christmas, my grandparents bought portable CD players and copies of Now! 1 for everybody. There would have been 8 other grandkids there, counting my sisters, and I still speak to 4 of them, counting my sisters. There were two grandparents, and I presently talk to neither, though, to be fair, the better one of them has been dead for 18 years. The other one's somewhere in Northern California, possibly making out-of-pocket observations about other people at this very moment. Did you know her accountant had two Jewish names? That's something she felt comfortable making a bunch of jokes about at a different Christmas dinner, after attending three of her grandchildren's bar and bat mitzvahs over the course of 5 years. She knew her stepson had married a Jewess who had raised three Jews, is what I'm saying. This was not a surprise to her when she pulled out all the comments about Jews and money.
There were 17 tracks on Now! 1, so this will be a long list, but it's funny, so I'm going to name all of the other artists who made the cut. In 1998, Virgin Records considered Radiohead's peers to be: Janet Jackson, Backstreet Boys, Fastball, Harvey Danger, Spice Girls, K-Ci & JoJo, All Saints, Tonic, Hanson, Cherry Poppin' Daddies, Imajin, Brian McKnight, Aqua, Everclear, Lenny Kravitz, Marcy Playground.
As far as cultural imprint and record sales go, Janet Jackson blows Radiohead out of the water. I'm not arguing Radiohead was the only real artist in the inaugural Now! cohort. As far as my taste goes, it is hilarious to see Radiohead sitting alongside Aqua and Cherry Poppin' Daddies on a compilation of cool music for teens. In fact, Radiohead didn't have any staying power– this was their only Now! appearance, but Fastball showed up again on Now! 3 and Everclear was on Now!s 2, 5 and 6. Radiohead are the rare band to make great music and become popular enough to headline the biggest festivals and share space with Tonic on a year-end survey of popular singles. Back in 1998, it was anybody's guess which one of those bands would keep growing.
I'll be honest about a very dumb, navel-gazey thought here. I wrote this post up during my lunch breaks last Thursday and Friday and let the draft sit over the weekend, planning to finish it on Monday. I should have hit send on Friday, because I'm reading Tom Breihan's "The Alternative Number Ones" column on Fastball's "The Way" right now and he's got a few sentences about Now That's What I Call Music. I'm worried you'll think I'm ripping him off. I promise I'm not.
There aren't many Now!-approved bands I'd enjoy listening to, but it's pretty cool they commissioned Piet Mondrian to do the cover art of Now! 53.

Music: "Mornings Eleven" by The Magic Numbers
Point of Contact: end credits of a bad movie
Beginning in 2005, The Magic Numbers were just the band filed next to two of my most frequented record store sections: "The Magnetic Fields" and "The Magnetic Fields (side projects)." And then, in 2007, I heard this song over the end credits of the Bob Odenkirk-directed, Will Forte-written comedy The Brothers Solomon. I definitely watched The Brothers Solomon because I love Odenkirk. I may not have known who Forte was at the time. The film was depressing. Odenkirk's one of the funniest people alive and he got the money together to make a movie and I was rooting for him, but it stunk. Cheers to the part of "Mornings Eleven" that sounds like "Unchained Melody." Jeers to the title seeming like it should have an apostrophe. It's been 19 years, I should probably give another Magic Numbers song a chance.
Music: "The Crying Game" by Boy George and the Pet Shop Boys
Point of Contact: The second-most transphobic scene in Ace Ventura: Pet Detective
When I was in my 20s, I watched and liked The Crying Game, Neil Jordan's 1992 IRA-themed neo-noir. That's where this cover of Dave Berry's "The Crying Game" comes from. In 1994, the same cover played over the Ace Ventura: Pet Detective scene where Ace realizes Lois Einhorn, who he's kissed, is trans, and he reacts by using a plunger on his mouth, burning his clothes, etc.
I can't pretend I was sensitive enough to the world to be upset by this at the time, because I wasn't in my 20s when I watched Jim Carrey barf in a garbage can. I was 5 when Ace Ventura hit and only a little older when my family bought the movie on video, and a person smothering himself with a toilet plunger seemed hilarious. I'm sure this shit did real damage to people, either for the way it reinforced bigots' ideas of trans identities as gross-out jokes, or the way it made trans women think about themselves.
I almost want to sit down with Ace Ventura again because of the Einhorn stuff. It's amazing how weird that movie's plot is when you take its twist into account: Miami Dolphins field goal kicker Ray Finkle flubs a kick, is blamed for a Super Bowl loss, is sent to an asylum for wanting to murder teammate Dan Marino, escapes the asylum and vanishes, kills a woman named Lois Einhorn and successfully assumes her identity, transitions her gender just to keep that ruse going, leaves a newspaper clipping about the real Einhorn's disappearance at the asylum, meaning she actually killed the hiker before being institutionalized, rises up the ranks of the Miami Police Department, ultimately becoming a Lieutenant, seduces the entire male police force and kidnaps a celebrity dolphin and, later, Marino in an effort to keep Miami from winning another Super Bowl.
The bigotry is inexcusable, but the way Ace Ventura's writers reverse-engineer their film's plot to accommodate it is astonishing, like something Raymond Chandler would write if you tricked him into a crack addiction. Trans woman steals world's most famous dolphin to get revenge on city that overreacted to her poor field goal attempt. It's certainly stranger than what Vincent Gallo did with the same Scott Norwood story.
Boy George has been a horrible asshole for at least a decade, but his voice is great here. More importantly, the Pet Shop Boys' production and instrumentation is gorgeous. Where the original sounds thin and tuneless, the Pet Shop Boys push the guitar way up to the front of the mix and give it a big, echoey gravity, so that this pretty synth slow dance number becomes an epic every time the main hook comes back around. I don't have much time for Boy George, I've never connected with Pet Shop Boys and the original "Crying Game" is nothing special, but this is a perfect song.
Music: Sea Power
Point of Contact: Target-branded webisodes
In 2005, Sea Power were called British Sea Power, and British Sea Power is a great band name. That year, Celebreality was picking up steam and I had the free time of a high school kid who hadn't yet started applying to colleges, so I watched a lot of VH1. This did to my soul what various now-banned coolants and aerosols did to the ozone layer.
VH1 showed constant ads for a webseries that showed what the youth were really going through, the ad was set to the Bloc Party b-side "Always New Depths" and it ended with a bunch of bands' names flashing across the screen. One of them was "British Sea Power," and the name sounded good enough for me to look them up on Pandora. I still love them. Great stuff. Never actually watched the webisodes.
It turns out a lot of people also saw those ads. Reddit is full of "Am I the only one who remembers that?" posts. It was called either oddsagainst7even or Odds Against 7even and it was put together by Target to sell their line of dorm furniture. Luckily, the series has been archived online, and I hope to make the time to watch some of it soon. I guess the idea was you'd watch college kids have little adventures and then you'd see them sit in their chairs and stow things in their cabinets and go buy those things from Target. One of the episodes apparently centered on booking a Hold Steady show and the product placement was minimal. The lack of product placement is either a lie or an indication Target was pouring money into new media campaigns to appeal to the kind of person who'd be wary of new media campaigns. The series was an Honoree for Best use of Video or Moving Image at the 2006 Webby Awards. The critics were in love. Tongues were wagging on Madison Avenue, folks.
The second half of Sea Power's "Bear" still gives me chills.
Also I learned about Glenn Branca from a flexi disc pressed into decades-old, rock hard pizza dough given out during the Papa John's Minimalist Papa Pairings promotion. The accompanying pie didn't have any toppings.